Transcript 0:00 Hey, Nuria. Hey, Julio. [laughs] We're back- We're back... with another one of our American Colony video conversations. 0:09 In episode eight, George Laws Garcia told us how leaving the island for college in Chicago and joining a Latino fraternity, meeting Chicago Ricans, actually broadened how he saw his own identity. 0:22 Right, and he ended up in Washington after several years of public service, and now he runs the Puerto Rico Statehood Council. And I sat down with him for the full conversation. 0:34 So here's Julio's conversation with George Laws Garcia. My name is George Laws Garcia. I'm the executive director of the Puerto Rico Statehood Council. 0:42 We are a non-profit organization based in Washington, DC, and our goal is to advance full equality and democracy for the US citizens of Puerto Rico through statehood. 0:52 And George, before we get into the questions, tell me your Puerto Rican story. 0:57 So my Puerto Rican story is that I was born and raised on the island, and a lot of people don't really understand that because when they see my name, George Henry Laws, they automatically think I'm a gringo, Pero soy boricuas, right? 1:11 And that's actually a reality for a lot of people in Puerto Rico. 1:14 I have other friends that also have American names, but they're born and raised on the island, and we're just as much Puerto Rican as anyone else is, right? So I'm born and raised on the island. 1:26 I went to University of Chicago for undergrad, and honestly, that is part of my Puerto Rican story too because as I came Stateside, having grown up on the island, part of what I realized is that in many ways 1:44 I had centered my Puerto Rican identity as kind of the core of who I was, and in coming to Chicago, I saw another Puerto Rican experience, which is- Yeah... the experience of Chicago Ricans. 1:57 And I joined a Hispanic fraternity, it's called La Unidad Latina, and that actually broadened my experience even further because in the Chicago chapter we had hermanos who were Puerto Rican and mostly Mexican, right? 2:10 So I, I kind of began to understand that my identity has different layers to it. Yeah, I'm Puerto Rican. I'm an American citizen and I'm American, but I'm also Latino and Hispanic, right? 2:24 I'm part of this kind of bigger group of, of people here within the US. And after University of Chicago, came to Washington, DC and decided to work on Puerto Rico issues. 2:35 So I worked for a national nonprofit called the National Puerto Rican Coalition. Right. I worked on issues related to the island, but also to the Puerto Rican community Stateside. 2:44 After that I worked for two governors of Puerto Rico, a member of Congress, a federal agency, and in all of them I continued to support the advancement of the people on the island, but doing it through working with the federal government and with the government of Puerto Rico. 3:00 I feel you when it comes to the whole like, "Wait a minute, I'm Puerto Rican but I'm hanging out with all these Latinos in a college campus, and wow, I have a lot more in common with some Mexican kid from the Southwest than I thought I did," right? 3:14 So I think that's a really great experience when you come from Puerto Rico and then you get into sort of the Latinidad of, of the United States. I'm really glad you brought that up. 3:22 But listen, when was the first time you, George Henry Laws, came to perceive Puerto Rico as a colony? 3:32 Because that word, that's such a charged word and it has a history, but a lot of us have come to this conclusion as Puerto Ricans. So do you have a specific story where you were like, "Man, Puerto Rico's a colony"? 3:44 I think the first time that I really kind of realized the relationship between Puerto Rico and the States was actually as a child. My parents took me on a trip to New York. 3:55 It was one of the first times that I remember traveling outside of Puerto Rico, and I asked my dad if we needed to change the money, right? Because, "Oh, they, they have dollars here too." 4:08 And for me, I was, "Well, this is just the money we use in Puerto Rico to buy, you know, whatever. We, we use the same things over here?" And they're like- Yeah... "No, no, no, it's the other way around. 4:18 Like, this is the money from the States and we use it in Puerto Rico." 4:22 And then I started to ask questions, and that's when the whole thing kind of began unraveling and opening up for me about the fact that Puerto Rico is part of the United States, but in many ways we're treated as being separate from the United States. 4:38 Yeah. We're, we're, w- you know, the famous Supreme Court ruling. So explain your current stance for our American Colony listeners. 4:46 Like where do you stand politically when it comes to political status for the future of the island? 4:51 Where I stand is that I firmly and wholeheartedly believe that the United States has a moral, political and value-based obligation to end this relationship that is just completely against America's own founding values, right? 5:13 So America was founded on this idea of government by consent of the governed. 5:16 It was enshrined in our Declaration of Independence, and the US Constitution and kind of everything that's flowed therefrom have been attempts to try to create a government that tries to live up to that in some way, right? 5:30 Some ways very successfully, in some ways very flawed, right? But in the case of Puerto Rico, those Supreme Court cases that you mentioned that are insular cases, they basically created a dead end, right? 5:41 Where before Puerto Rico there was a Northwest Ordinance where all territories were ultimately destined to become states, and it made sense. You, you acquire additional territory, you, you make... The people there are... 5:52 become your citizens, and then ultimately they get organized, they have a functional society and you admit them as states, you grow the union and everyone gets stronger because of it, right? 6:02 In the case of Puerto Rico, we were acquired by the United States, we were made a part of the United States, we were made citizens of the United States. 6:10 But then we're left in this dead end where basically we have unequal rights and we have no representation at the federal level, and, and that needs to, needs to end. 6:23 Yeah, no, I, I think you bring up the insular cases, and it's one of the themes that we've brought out through the season of American Colony. 6:29 I mean, not only in episode one with what Nuria and I did, but also episode five when we, when we talk about the Jones Act, and Balzac versus Puerto Rico, and sort of that time in sort of the early 20th century where Puerto Rico's fate was decided. 6:45 And, you know, it's pretty clear that, for lack of a better word, constitutional rights that happen on the archipelago, they don't happen. 6:55 We literally can get on a plane, and our constitutional rights, if we claim residency in Puerto Rico, are very different from you or I living over here as, as Puerto Ricans living in the mainland. 7:06 Where do you think, understanding sort of the politics of all this, because it is very complicated, I do think there's a new cur- current, like, wave of 7:16 non-aligned colonial party statehood supporters that I wanted to bring in into this conversation, and you've al- you and I have always had conversations that would have been incredibly respectful. 7:27 Where is this going next? 7:29 So I think the main thing for me is I take a historic perspective, and if we look at the processes that have been happening with Puerto Rico's participation in Washington, DC and in Congress at the federal level, what we actually see is a pattern of progressive improvement in the amount of recognition that there is about, first, the problem, and then about the need to resolve it, right? 7:59 We haven't gotten to the, the threshold that's necessary for a lot of paths, but if you look at it from a big picture perspective, we're actually getting closer, right? Mm-hmm. 8:09 And I'll just throw a couple of facts at you. 8:12 Obviously, Puerto Rico, the current constitution established in 1952, the first set of issues that were brought up to Congress about people being unsatisfied with that because they were sold on this myth of the commonwealth, which ended up really just being a fancy name for continued territory status. 8:32 So the first referendum was, like, 1967, and it already started to show that some people wanted independence and statehood, but the version of the commonwealth that was presented on the ballot at the time was also, like, a complete exercise in wishful thinking. 8:48 It, it doesn't actually exist within the US Constitution. That was a real problem. We kind of moved from there. There was more and more concerns that were brought up. 8:57 Obviously, the stranglehold that the popular Democratic Party had on Puerto Rico politics broke, and you finally had other political parties, like the New Progressive Party, the pro-statehood party, have a governor in Luis Pereira, later on Carlos Romero Barceló. 9:12 You ended up in the '80s with this Bennett Johnston process, right? And that was the first time the US Senate really took this issue seriously. 9:21 There was some genuine thoughtful debate and ideas put together as to what a self-executing process to let Puerto Rico decide its future and how to implement that would be that would actually inform people about what their options and choices were and the consequences of those. 9:41 So that's 1989. 1998, we have the Young Bill, which passed the House, I think it was by one or two votes, right? 9:50 This was during Pedro Rosselló being governor, and Romero Barceló was resident commissioner, was a huge success at the time, but didn't go anywhere in the Senate. 9:59 It did lead to, you know, another plebiscite that was locally held. That plebiscite was inconclusive. 10:05 There were more votes for statehood than for any of the other options, but none of the above won, which is- Was that none of the above? That's so typically Puerto Rican. Yeah. 10:12 Why people have not been able to make a choice that's clear is because Congress has not been clear about what it's willing to offer to the people- Yeah... of Puerto Rico, right? Yeah. 10:22 And o- one of the things that I think is really important for your listeners to understand is that a lot of talk is had about self-determination, but the reality is that self-determination is actually a bi-directional process. 10:34 It's both the US figuring out, "Oh my God, I have this relationship that's non-consensual with 3 million of my own citizens. That's messed up. It goes against my values. It damages American democracy. 10:47 I have to change that." But then they have to self-determine it in terms of asking themselves the question, "Well, what non-territorial options am I willing to offer Puerto Rico, and on what terms?" 10:58 And the people of Puerto Rico, who've clearly expressed that they no longer consent to Puerto Rico being a territory, so going back to my timeline, in 2010, we had the Puerto Rico, I think it was the Puerto Rico Status Act. 11:12 It had the highest level of support at that time- Right... among any other legislation that had passed the House. It passed with a bipartisan support because Pedro Pierluisi, a Democrat, was resident commissioner. 11:25 Luis Fortuño, a Republican, who at that time I worked for, was governor, but the bill was non-binding, right? 11:31 The Senate didn't take it up, and that passage of that bill in 2010 is what led to the plebiscite in 2012, right? 11:39 We have to say, because I have been critical of the plebiscites, but that was a conclusive first question that says, "Do you support the current territorial status of Puerto Rico, yes or no?" 11:49 And for the first time, right, in history, right, people were like, "No, I don't." 11:54 And I feel like we've been stuck there since 2012 to get to this notion and of where we are now with all the plebiscites of how many more of these do we have to have before Congress realizes that they are the ones, right? 12:08 I hate to say this to people, but Congress gets to dictate. They have to determine this, right? Yeah. But the reality is why not put all your energies into convincing Congress that it's time for a binding something? 12:21 If I could just kind of run through the, the legislative and, and the plebiscites, I think we get to that point, which is- Going back to the question you asked me of what comes next, right? Yeah. 12:31 So the plebiscite was held in twenty twelve. First question, do you want to continue being a territory, yes or no? And the answer was no. Right. The majority said, "We don't want to continue being a territory," right? 12:41 And then the second question was which of the non-territorial options do you prefer? Statehood, independence, or a form of independence called free association, right? And the majority voted for statehood. Right. 12:50 This is the first time that there was ever a majority vote for statehood. 12:55 There was a lot that was made about the importance of people who submitted a ballot but did not choose one of the options, and this is the whole blank ballot. You know what I have to say about the blank ballot. 13:08 It's like- What? You didn't vote, period. If you have a choice to make and you don't make a choice, you're abdicating your right to make that choice- I-... 13:17 and you're allowing the other people who made a choice to choose for you, end of story. 13:20 I have gotten to s- I have gotten to so many spirited discussions with, "Well, these votes should count," and all that, but it's like they don't because we don't know- Yeah... what people voted. 13:31 I always tell people, "Why didn't you just choose something?" Yeah. Yeah. 13:34 So there was a number of bills that were presented after that, and I think the big change was that the bills changed from just saying, "Hey, voters, choose an option," to, "Okay, so you've chosen an option. 13:50 How do we actually implement that?" Right? And you had your first statehood yes or no bill that was presented in Congress- Right... that had an actual execution mechanism. 13:59 And that by itself is kind of a big change because it's not just asking people's opinion, but actually proposing that Congress offer people a choice where whatever people choose actually gets executed, which is going to the core issue of establishing consent of the governed. 14:15 Because if I'm just giving you a choice, but then it doesn't change anything, then that's just a poll, right? Yeah. 14:22 So w- what we had then is another plebiscite that was held in twenty, uh, seventeen, uh, between statehood, independence with or without free association, or the continued territory status. Right. 14:36 And statehood won by, like, ninety-seven percent, but majority of people- There are people like, "We didn't vote," and then Hurricane Maria happens, and then there's another plebiscite. Yeah, yeah. 14:47 Twenty twenty vote was a vote on statehood, yes or no. Yes. And statehood won again by a majority, right? Right. And then we get to the period... And that was the first time ever that Puerto Rico has voted on that. 15:01 Everyone who didn't want to vote for statehood could vote no, whether you wanted independence or free association or continued territory status, or you wanna be reunified with Spain, which is one of the proposals that's out there now by, you know, fringe groups, right? 15:15 In twenty twenty-one, we had a, a bill that was introduced that was the Puerto Rico Statehood Admission Act, and then in response to that, Nydia Velazquez and AOC presented the Puerto Rico Self-Determination Act. 15:27 The Puerto Rico Statehood Admission Act said Puerto Ricans have voted for statehood. They've done it three times, so here's a bill that implements statehood if they vote on it one more time, right? 15:37 And what Nydia Velazquez and AOC said is, "Wait, but people haven't actually had the opportunity to deliberate this enough, so we need to start a constitutional convention that Congress authorizes people of Puerto Rico to do," and then you would end up with definitions, and then that gets voted on, and then Congress ultimately may or may not ratify that. 15:59 We went through the whole process of debating that in the committee. 16:02 Both bills, I think, saw that it was completely clear that they could cancel each other out, and neither one would move anywhere, and we started what is one of the most significant processes possible, which is to actually think through how do we develop a process where the focus is not just, let me push this option, or let me just deliberate this ad nauseam but never reach a solution, but how do we actually come up with a set of definitions that are agreed on by everyone, and a process where ultimately voters choose between the legitimate options, and then whatever they choose actually gets implemented. 16:44 Yeah. And that took the rest of twenty twenty-one and most of twenty twenty-two to go through legislative process, but ultimately it passed the House. Yeah, that was big. 16:54 It passed the House with bipartisan support at a moment- That was huge... where Republican-Democratic division is massive. No, it was huge. That was a huge moment, but then there was another plebiscite. Yeah, yeah. 17:04 The last plebiscite was based on the legislation that was passed in twenty twenty-two- In the House... in the House. Right. 17:11 It literally took the exact same ballot language, everything that had been negotiated, and the ballot presented three options, statehood, independence, and the form of independence called free association, right? 17:21 And the majority of citizens, sixty-eight percent, voted for statehood, right? So it's like the fourth vote where a majority chooses statehood since twenty twelve. 17:32 Where we're at now is obviously we have a Congress that has not wanted to take this issue on, either in the House or in the Senate, in any way, and we have a president that's just been focused on other things, and honestly is just not interested in addressing this issue in any way whatsoever as far as I've seen. 17:50 How does that make you feel as you advocate? Because what keeps you going then during these times, George? Well, you know, it's frustrating, but there's a saying, "It's always darkest before dawn." 18:02 Looking at it from my perspective, where we're at now is in anticipation of the next legislative window of opportunity that is going to open up, because at some point the current Congress is gonna change, right? 18:16 November's right around the corner. 18:18 At some point, the current president is no longer gonna be in the White House, and at some point all of the learning that we've done about how to work this process through the relationship building that we've been doing between different movements that are not aligned on status But all fundamentally love Puerto Rico, care about Puerto Rico, want it to do better, and know that part of doing that is dismantling the structure of colonialism. 18:46 All of the learning that we've achieved in Congress, where there's more and more people that get it, that just fixing Medicaid or fixing NAP to SNAP or fixing this other detail is not enough, that you actually have to get to the, you know, core structure of the issue to enable Puerto Rico to actually open up to its full potential. 19:05 All of those things are going to converge. 19:07 And where we're at now is continuing to create the conditions for that to occur, and strengthening the statehood movement to think beyond just the political parties and the individual leaders that have led it in the past. 19:21 Because a lot of times the movements have been absorbed just by their leaders or by their parties that they represent. Yeah. 19:27 And we're really focusing on that citizen advocate connection and that connection to the broader American public. 19:34 Do you think that let's address this colonialism no matter what position we are from, at least from a legislative advocacy lobbying effort that's happening with all the groups, that that has been the biggest sort of win difference that has happened over your career? 19:51 That people from different camps are talking to each other and being like, "Yeah, we're a colony." 19:55 I, I think that's a fundamental change because colonialism has a very specific logic to it, and it's an interlocking logic, right? And the logic is a logic of divide and conquer. It's very simple. 20:08 It's been used for millennia. And part of the logic is you pit the pro-statehood folks against the pro-Commonwealth folks against the pro-independence folks. Each one tells the other, "Oh, but your option is impossible. 20:20 Your option's impossible. Your option's impossible." They fight against each other, and the system of colonialism persists, right? So when those three, and any other who want to join, actually say, "You know what? 20:32 It's more important for me to actually end this structure of territorial colonialism than it is for me to advance the immediate interest of my own individual ideology," then you open up a path where you actually expand the field of possibility because you create a process that has legitimacy and allows people to ultimately make a choice, right? 20:57 Yeah. And you're taking a risk because people could choose something that you don't want. 21:01 But ultimately, that risk is worth taking because what all three groups share, and anyone else who doesn't believe in either of those or any of those share, is we love Puerto Rico. 21:14 Thank you, George, and thank you, Julio, for that conversation. This conversation is also available in Spanish in our feed, so check it out. And you can also follow us at the Latino Newsletter on social media. 21:26 A big shout-out to Shake It Easy Media for co-producing this series with us. We're very excited. 21:32 And you can subscribe to the Latino Newsletter at thelatinonewsletter.org and also on all our social media networks at the Latino Newsletter. So we will be back. Gracias. 21:43 [outro music]